< Back to latest news & events

News

Oral Proceedings by videoconference (VICO) in oppositions proceedings to become permanent

November 2022

The pilot project for oral proceedings in opposition proceedings by video conference (VICO) started during the pandemic and has received positive feedback.[1]

The President of the EPO has therefore declared (Decision of 22 November 2022) that, as of 1 January 2023, VICOs will become the default format for oral proceedings in opposition. Only in exceptional circumstances when the opposition division permits it, will oral proceedings in opposition be conducted in person.

The president believes that VICO has enabled parties to save on time and money whilst reducing carbon emissions from travelling in person.

Accordingly oral proceedings will only be held in person if requested by a party or at the instigation of the Opposition Division if there are serious reasons against holding the proceedings by video conference. If a party’s request is refused the refusal is not separately appealable.

Given the experience during the pandemic, and as set out in the Pilot Project Final Report [1], the taking of evidence, including hearing witnesses and inspection, has been successfully conducted by VICO and so is not likely to amount to serious reasons for conducting oral proceedings in person. An exception may be where inspection cannot be adequately conducted using video equipment.

Please see here for the official notice from the EPO.

The decision of the President does not affect Oral Proceedings at the Boards of Appeal. Indeed, in the Enlarged Board of Appeal Decision G1/21 the Enlarged Board clearly stated that whilst oral proceedings by VICO were compatible with the right to be heard enshrined in the EPC they were suboptimal compared with in-person hearings and, as such, in-person hearings should, in the absence of a pandemic, be the default option (Reason 45).

Accordingly we do not expect the President’s Decision to have a knock-on effect at the Board of Appeal.

For further information please contact Dr Chris Moore, Head of Oppositions & Appeals.

[1] Pilot Project Final Report November 2022 (here) – over 77% of respondents found oral proceedings to be “good” or “very good”

Latest updates

IP Ingredients, Part 13: Navigating Trade Marks in the World of Food and Drink Rebranding

In the dynamic world of the food and drink industry, rebranding can be a strategic tool used by companies to refresh their image, capture new markets, or adapt to changing …

Read article
Event - 9th May 2024

HGF's 10th Annual IP in Healthcare Conference 2024

We are delighted to invite you to HGF’s 10th annual IP in Healthcare Conference. This year’s theme focuses on emerging technologies. We will review the latest intellectual property issues and …

Event details

Crafting a claim for AI in medtech: Two case studies

As artificial intelligence creates a complex legal landscape for healthcare and medtech, Janine Swarbrick of HGF explores two case studies that shed light on how to claim an AI invention. …

Read article

Intellectual Property (IP) and its role in innovation during the energy transition

The shift from fossil fuels to greener energy will profoundly impact the profitability of many businesses in the energy sector. However, innovation has become an essential facilitator of the energy …

Read article

More than just ‘Patent Protected’: How Intellectual Property (IP) can fuel collaboration and growth

Traditionally, intellectual property (IP) protection is viewed as a mechanism to create a monopoly and exclude competitors. For example, patents give the owner the right to stop others from using …

Read article

HGF continues to grow with 7 new promotions

It gives us great pleasure to announce that seven members of our team have been promoted from Director to Partner. These promotions will be effective from the 1st of May …

Read article