Agritech Thymes: The Bite of Implied Consent: Lessons from the Pink Lady Case

Published October 2025

Agritech Thymes: The Bite of Implied Consent: Lessons from the Pink Lady Case

  • Can the supply of a plant variety without clear and defined restrictions on its use be an implicit consent to commercialise it?

This case centres on the evidence required to establish “serious doubts” regarding novelty of the well-known Cripps Pink (“Pink Lady”) and Cripps Red (“Sundowner”) apple varieties. As a reminder, novelty of a plant variety right is assessed using a test of “commercial novelty”, rather than a test of “absolute novelty” as used in patent law.

The EU General Court decision (T-159/24) reaffirms that implicit consent to commercialise a plant variety can undermine its EU plant variety right (CPVR) protection.  The Court decided that the supply of varieties to nurseries without clear restrictions as regards their use long before filing the CPVR applications was enough to provide implicit consent to exploit them commercially, to the detriment of their EU plant variety rights.

The takeaway? Even if the intention is merely to hand out new varieties for testing purposes in commercially relevant field trials, it is best to expressly limit the use of new varieties for testing or research purposes to preserve their novelty in a subsequent CPVR application.

The Court also addressed the role of declarations as evidence. It confirmed that declarations may carry weight even without supporting documentation, provided they’re credible, made by impartial parties, and consistent with other evidence.

In short, record-keeping and express limitations regarding commercial uses in contracts are key. Creators of new varieties should document when varieties are disposed of and retain evidence of any use restrictions placed on those varieties to mitigate the possibility of a third party establishing “serious doubts” regarding the novelty of the variety.

Click the button below to read our full article.

Latest updates

Event - 12th November 2026

HGF Partners with PPTI for 'Designing Foods for Healthy Aging' Webinar

As healthy aging, metabolic health and weight management rise up the consumer agenda, food and nutrition businesses are increasingly looking beyond traditional product development and towards solutions that deliver measurable …

Event details

Basel Seminar: Seminar on the new EU Pharma Package and its implications for regulatory exclusivities in the EU

Venue – Der Teufelhof Basel, Switzerland We are pleased to invite you to our seminar on the new EU Pharma Package and its implications for regulatory exclusivities in the EU. …

Read article
Event - 28th October 2026

HGF Attending BMCS Antibody–Drug Conjugates 2026

HGF is pleased to announce that Dr Thomas Lonsdale, Patent Director, will be attending the BMCS Antibody–Drug Conjugates 2026 meeting, taking place on 19 November 2026 at GSK, Stevenage, UK. …

Event details

Hsu Min Chung Recognised in IAM Global Leaders 2027

HGF is delighted to announce that Partner, Hsu Min Chung, has been recognised in the IAM Global Leaders 2027 guide, a prestigious ranking that highlights some of the world’s leading …

Read article
Event - 28th October 2026

HGF Attending the KINPA Conference 2026

HGF is pleased to be attending the KINPA Conference 2026, taking place on 28 October in Seoul, South Korea. Recognised as Korea’s largest intellectual property gathering, the conference brings together …

Event details
Event - 17th - 19th November 2026

HGF Attending IPBC Asia 2026

HGF is pleased to announce that Partner, Dr Jennifer Uno, will be attending IPBC Asia 2026, taking place from 17-19 November 2026 in Tokyo, Japan. The event is one of …

Event details

HGF Recognised in the Chambers and Partners UK 2027 Guide

HGF is proud to announce that we have once again been recognised in the Chambers and Partners UK 2027 Guide, with outstanding rankings for both the firm and individual practitioners …

Read article
Event - 4th November 2026

IAM Navigating the UPC conference

HGF are gold sponsors of the IAM Live Navigating the UPC conference. IAM Live: Navigating the UPC returns to Paris in November bringing together over 180 industry leaders for an …

Event details