Paying the price of a blocking order

Published Juni 2018

Paying the price of a blocking order

This month the Supreme Court has answered the question as to who should bear the costs of Internet Service Providers (ISPs) implementing website blocking orders in relation to trade mark infringements. Overturning the decisions of the lower courts, the Supreme Court decided that the cost of compliance with the blocking order should be paid by the trade mark owners and not the ISPs.

Background

In the case of Cartier International AG and others v British Telecommunications Plc and another [2018] UKSC 28. the trade mark owners identified 46,000 websites offering counterfeits and sought injunctions requiring the ISPs to block or attempt to block access to these specified websites. The injunction was granted by the High Court and the ISPs were ordered to pay the costs of implementing the website-blocking order. Whilst many injunctions have been granted against ISPs on the application of copyright-owners, this was the first time that a website blocking injunction was granted to protect a trade mark.

The main issue facing the Supreme Court was whether it was correct that the ISPs should have been required to bear the costs of implementing the website-blocking orders. It decided that the lower courts had got the issue wrong and that these costs of compliance should be paid by the trade mark owners.

ISPs as “Innocent Intermediaries”

The Supreme Court held that the role of the ISPs in this particular case was a to provide a passive, technical services with no editorial control and they were unlikely to know and had no duty to discover website content. The Supreme Court emphasised the ISPs were innocent intermediaries, themselves not guilty of trade mark infringement and as such it was not justifiable that they should pay the costs of complying with the blocking injunction. The trade mark owners should pick up these costs.

Responsibilities of Intermediaries

Although “innocent intermediaries” in this case, ISPs are not absolved of responsibility in all circumstances. In this instance, the ISPs were found to be “mere conduits” under Article 12 of the E-commerce Directive owing to their limited role in merely providing a communications network. However, different considerations may apply to intermediary internet services engaging in caching or hosting, as such activities involve greater participation in the infringement and are more likely to infringe national IP laws if a safe harbour immunity is unavailable. The immunity for hosting requires ISPs to take the same steps as soon as it becomes aware of any illegality or of facts from which it is apparent.

Should an intermediary breach such requirements to assist, they will lose such immunity, but whether that results in liability will depend on the provisions of national law.

What the future holds…

This judgment confirms that trade mark owners seeking to block access to websites selling infringing goods should be aware that any injunctions against ISPs will come at a cost. What will be interesting is whether the Courts will in future apply these changes to copyright cases. In the meantime, however, rights holders should approach with caution in seeking injunctions from any third-party internet services that can be considered “mere conduits”. The judgment appears to suggest that the result may be different in actions against other more active providers of internet services including web hosting, internet search engines, portals and internet payment systems. It is however indicated that more is required by such intermediaries rather than mere non-compliance with the conditions of immunity in the E-commerce Directive for such third parties to be liable for costs of a website-blocking injunction.

Aktuelle Neuigkeiten

Event - 12. November 2026

HGF Partners with PPTI for 'Designing Foods for Healthy Aging' Webinar

As healthy aging, metabolic health and weight management rise up the consumer agenda, food and nutrition businesses are increasingly looking beyond traditional product development and towards solutions that deliver measurable …

Veranstaltungsdetails
Event - 15. Dezember 2026

Basel Seminar: Seminar on the new EU Pharma Package and its implications for regulatory exclusivities in the EU

Venue – Der Teufelhof Basel, Switzerland We are pleased to invite you to our seminar on the new EU Pharma Package and its implications for regulatory exclusivities in the EU. …

Veranstaltungsdetails
Event - 28. Oktober 2026

HGF Attending BMCS Antibody–Drug Conjugates 2026

HGF is pleased to announce that Dr Thomas Lonsdale, Patent Director, will be attending the BMCS Antibody–Drug Conjugates 2026 meeting, taking place on 19 November 2026 at GSK, Stevenage, UK. …

Veranstaltungsdetails

Hsu Min Chung Recognised in IAM Global Leaders 2027

HGF is delighted to announce that Partner, Hsu Min Chung, has been recognised in the IAM Global Leaders 2027 guide, a prestigious ranking that highlights some of the world’s leading …

Weiterlesen
Event - 28. Oktober 2026

HGF nimmt an der KINPA-Konferenz 2026 teil

HGF freut sich auf die Teilnahme an der KINPA-Konferenz 2026, die am 28. Oktober in Seoul, Südkorea, stattfindet. Als Koreas größte Veranstaltung zum Thema geistiges Eigentum bringt die Konferenz mehr …

Veranstaltungsdetails
Event - 17. bis 19. November 2026

HGF nimmt an der IPBC Asia 2026 teil

HGF freut sich bekannt zu geben, dass Partnerin Dr. Jennifer Uno an der IPBC Asia 2026 teilnehmen wird, die vom 17. bis 19. November 2026 in Tokio, Japan, stattfindet. Als …

Veranstaltungsdetails

HGF im Chambers and Partners UK Guide 2027 ausgezeichnet

HGF freut sich, erneut im Chambers and Partners UK Guide 2027 ausgezeichnet worden zu sein. Sowohl die Kanzlei als auch einzelne Berufsträger haben in mehreren Regionen hervorragende Platzierungen erzielt. Der …

Weiterlesen
Event - 4. November 2026

IAM Navigating the UPC conference

HGF are gold sponsors of the IAM Live Navigating the UPC conference. IAM Live: Navigating the UPC returns to Paris in November bringing together over 180 industry leaders for an …

Veranstaltungsdetails