The Deity Shoes case: a question of design activity and the constraints on a designer’s freedom

Published January 2026

The Deity Shoes case: a question of design activity and the constraints on a designer’s freedom

The footwear brand Deity Shoes sought to enforce their Community Design rights, both registered and unregistered, against Mundorama Confort and Stay Design. However, Mundorama Confort and Stay Design found fault in Deity Shoes’ case, arguing that they should not have design protection in the first place. Indeed, these designs were simply the result of customised elements like buckles and laces from earlier designs included in supplier catalogues.  They did not have ‘genuine design activity’ or ‘intellectual effort’. This posed the question of whether these concepts were truly necessary for community design protection.

In light of this, the Spanish courts, where the case was first heard, decided to stay the proceedings and refer  the following questions to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) in order to determine the matter:

  1. Does there need to be ‘genuine design activity’ and ‘intellectual effort’ to obtain Community Design protection?
  2. Could customisation of designs from the supplier catalogues be seen as having individual character?
  3. Is a specific degree of customisation necessary for there to be authorship?
  4. Do fashion trends restrict a designer’s freedom?
  1. Legal Framework

To fully explore the implications of the final decision, it is necessary to understand the key legal provisions surrounding the requirements for Community Design protection and those that were ultimately considered in the decision. The source of these provisions is Regulation (EC) No. 6/2002 of 12th December 2001, which seeks to encourage innovation (recital 7).

The key requirements for protection are that a product must be a design and that it must be new and have individual character (article 4)

Specifically, a design should protect the appearance of a product (Article 3), while individual character means that the design produces a different overall impression on the informed user, taking into account the designer’s freedom (Recitals 14 and 19 and Articles 6 and 10). Novelty requires that no identical design must previously have been made available to the public (article 5). The right to the design automatically  lies with the designer or his successor (article 14)

  1. Advocate General Opinion

Before the CJEU provided a  final ruling, the Advocate General provided an Opinion on this matter below.

  1. The First and Third Questions

The process of how the design was created or ‘intellectual effort’ of the designer  is irrelevant when it comes to Community Design protection, which simply protects appearance.

The Advocate General also argued that the two conditions of novelty and individual character are exhaustive, meaning that ‘genuine design activity’ and ‘intellectual effort’ are not actually considerations. These elements lean more towards Copyright protection,  which seeks to protect originality.

Case law further dictates that protection cannot be denied due to constraints like technical function, highlighting that design activity and intellectual effort are not necessary for protection.

Moreover, the role of article 14 is to determine who the designer is, rather than to consider whether there is a link between “design” and “designer’ as there is between “work” and “author” in Copyright protection.

  1. The Second and Fourth Questions

As long as Deity Shoes’ customised designs, produced a different overall impression, they would have individual character, in line with this requirement.

The Advocate General also highlighted the fact that we must consider technical constraints and standardisation of designs in order to understand the designer’s freedom and to qualify the assessment of individual character overall. The more restricted the designer’s freedom the more likely small differences will allow protection. If this was not the case, then it would be very difficult to obtain protection and those who did obtain protection could potentially obtain a monopoly, which would stifle creativity.

When we consider the fashion industry specifically, this sector  would particularly suffer if fashion trends restricted design freedom, as the sector thrives on creativity and innovation. It follows that, although fashion trends can sometimes be considered in assessing the overall impression in an individual character assessment, they cannot be given the same weight as design/technical trends in restricting design freedom.

  1. CJEU

The CJEU considered the questions of the referring court and reached a conclusion in relation to each of these.

  1. The First and Third Questions

The CJEU ultimately argued that, the concepts of ‘genuine design activity’ or ‘intellectual effort’ are not necessary for protection as a community design. The key considerations are appearance, novelty and individual character, considering the designer’s freedom. The concepts of ‘genuine design activity’ and ‘intellectual effort’ lent more towards Copyright protection.

In terms of authorship, ‘the designer [does not undergo a specific process to obtain protection]’, so a specific degree of customisation is unnecessary.

  1. The Second and Fourth Questions

Regarding the second and fourth questions, the CJEU stated that the customisation of designs, such as those produced by Deity shoes, could have individual character. This was, because individual character is assessed through ‘the relationship between those designs and other prior designs’ . In this way, it would be possible for a community design to be ‘composed of various prior designs where taken individually the resulting design does not produce the same overall impression’.

The CJEU further agreed with the Advocate General’s opinion that the ‘features linked to fashion trends differ from those linked to the technical function of the product or to applicable legal requirements’ and so fashion trends cannot limit the freedom of the designer, which are considered from the perspective of the informed user. This would not suit the innovative and evolving nature of fashion overall.

  1. Practical implications

Ultimately, there is no need for ‘genuine design activity’ or ‘intellectual effort’ for community design protection, clearly distinguishing community designs from Copyright, which does require originality. In light of this, customisation such as that completed by Deity Shoes can obtain Community design protection. This highlights that Community designs are better suited to products that are more functional and can be mass produced

The distinction between design and copyright protection, is something that would be important for designers to consider regarding any IP Strategy.


This article was prepared by Trade Mark Attorney Melissa Buamah.

Latest updates

Event - 12th November 2026

HGF Partners with PPTI for 'Designing Foods for Healthy Aging' Webinar

As healthy aging, metabolic health and weight management rise up the consumer agenda, food and nutrition businesses are increasingly looking beyond traditional product development and towards solutions that deliver measurable …

Event details
Event - 15th December 2026

Basel Seminar: Seminar on the new EU Pharma Package and its implications for regulatory exclusivities in the EU

Venue – Der Teufelhof Basel, Switzerland We are pleased to invite you to our seminar on the new EU Pharma Package and its implications for regulatory exclusivities in the EU. …

Event details
Event - 28th October 2026

HGF Attending BMCS Antibody–Drug Conjugates 2026

HGF is pleased to announce that Dr Thomas Lonsdale, Patent Director, will be attending the BMCS Antibody–Drug Conjugates 2026 meeting, taking place on 19 November 2026 at GSK, Stevenage, UK. …

Event details

Hsu Min Chung Recognised in IAM Global Leaders 2027

HGF is delighted to announce that Partner, Hsu Min Chung, has been recognised in the IAM Global Leaders 2027 guide, a prestigious ranking that highlights some of the world’s leading …

Read article
Event - 28th October 2026

HGF Attending the KINPA Conference 2026

HGF is pleased to be attending the KINPA Conference 2026, taking place on 28 October in Seoul, South Korea. Recognised as Korea’s largest intellectual property gathering, the conference brings together …

Event details
Event - 17th - 19th November 2026

HGF Attending IPBC Asia 2026

HGF is pleased to announce that Partner, Dr Jennifer Uno, will be attending IPBC Asia 2026, taking place from 17-19 November 2026 in Tokyo, Japan. The event is one of …

Event details

HGF Recognised in the Chambers and Partners UK 2027 Guide

HGF is proud to announce that we have once again been recognised in the Chambers and Partners UK 2027 Guide, with outstanding rankings for both the firm and individual practitioners …

Read article
Event - 4th November 2026

IAM Navigating the UPC conference

HGF are gold sponsors of the IAM Live Navigating the UPC conference. IAM Live: Navigating the UPC returns to Paris in November bringing together over 180 industry leaders for an …

Event details