< Back to latest news & events

Blogs

Blog Series: IP Ingredients, Part 1: Can you patent a recipe?

November 2023

A patent is a legal right that enables the patent holder to prevent others from making and using their invention in the country where the patent is granted.  To many people, the word “invention” is suggestive of a highly technological innovation, such as an electronic device or perhaps a new drug.

While the European Patent Convention does not actually define what an “invention” is (but instead lists what it is not), the term “invention” inherently requires something to have a technical character.  However, this does not necessarily equate to “hi-tech”, nor does it limit patent protection to disruptive technologies – patents can be awarded for both ground-breaking innovations as well as relatively incremental improvements, in technical fields as diverse as space craft and chocolate wrappers.

Patents are granted for inventions that are novel and inventive.  By “novel”, it is meant that the invention has never been disclosed before, anywhere in the world, in any language.  The “inventive” requirement is a more subjective hurdle, but generally means that the innovation is not an obvious development of something that has been done previously.

So, returning to the question, what about recipes?  A family recipe that has been passed down through the generations is unlikely to be patentable since it is not novel (unless the family has somehow managed to keep it a well-guarded secret).  An idea to substitute one ingredient of a known recipe for another similar ingredient might result in a recipe which is novel, but probably would not be considered inventive under the patent system (unless the substitute ingredient produces an unexpected effect).  Presenting the recipe in a stylised form in a new book is an aesthetic creation which is subject to copyright, rather than being an invention.

However, this is not to say that recipes are not patentable.  On the contrary, many patents are granted for new food and beverage compositions that provide a particular advantage over previous compositions. For example, Cargill Inc’s European patent EP3496546B1 relates to a chocolate composition comprising particular types of cocoa butter, milk fat and emulsifier, which is said to provide improved colour.

Also in the confectionery field, Kraft’s GB patent GB2575549B covers a chocolate composition comprising soluble corn fibre, thereby enabling the amount of sugar in the composition to be reduced. The problem of reducing the sugar content of drinks while achieving a sweetening profile similar to that of natural sugar is addressed by Red Bull’s European patent EP3342294B1, which claims a sweetening composition comprising a natural sugar, a stevia compound and a tannin, and its use in beverages. 

The novelty and inventiveness of a food or beverage composition may lie in a particular combination of ingredients which haven’t previously been used together.  Alternatively, the combination of ingredients may already be known, but their use in specific ratios that leads to a surprising effect (e.g. a new taste sensation) may constitute a patentable invention.

So, how do you know whether you have a recipe (i.e. a composition) that might be patentable?  Here are a few questions for you to consider:

(1)    As far as you know, does your composition include a completely new ingredient, a new combination of ingredients, or a known combination of ingredients in new amounts?

(2)    Does the composition provide an advantage over previous similar compositions?

(3)    Would it have been obvious to someone working in your field that the new feature (e.g. the ingredient, combination or amounts) would give rise to that advantage?  Put another way, was the effect produced by the new feature surprising?

If you have answered “yes” to these questions, then your recipe may be patentable.  Keeping a log of recipe developments, in particular noting unexpected effects or how technical difficulties have been overcome, can help you to spot potentially new and inventive compositions (and processes for making them) that may constitute patentable subject-matter.  Any potentially patentable inventions should be discussed with a patent attorney before disclosing them to third parties, so that a decision can be made as to whether to file a patent application.  As for whether you should file a patent application, we will discuss that question along with wider considerations of IP strategy later in the IP Ingredients series.

For any questions relating to the above, or relating to any aspect of patenting, please contact the author, Dr. Jennifer Bailey at [email protected].

 


This article was prepared by Partner & Patent Attorney Jennifer Bailey.

Latest updates

HGF ranked band 1 in Chambers and Partners UK 2025

Chambers and Partners UK 2025 guide is now live. HGF is proud to be highly ranked as a firm and to have five ranked individuals. HGF is ranked band 1 …

Read article

The EPO Looks at the Morality and Patentability of Therapeutics Derived from Traditional Knowledge

This case (T2510/181) heard before the Technical Boards of Appeal at the EPO in May 2024 relates to the morality and novelty of substances of a natural origin. The invention …

Read article
Event - 7th November 2024

CIPSC Corporate IP Strategy Conference

HGF are proud to be platinum sponsors of the CIPSC event in Santa Clara, US. The CIPSC Unified Patents event will be held in Santa Clara, US on Thursday 7th …

Event details
Event - 7th November 2024

OUI Annual Networking Event

HGF are proud to be sponsoring the OUI Annual Networking Event in London on Thursday 7th November. This event will host key discussions around the impact of the Oxford’s Innovation …

Event details

Bite-sized MBA Course

HGF are proud to announce 14 of our colleagues have completed a bite-sized MBA and have now achieved a strategy consultation accreditation awarded from The University of East Anglia. The …

Read article
Event - 24th October 2024

CTA Demo Day

HGF is proud to be speaking at the Cancer Tech Accelerator Demo Day 2024. The Cancer Tech Accelerator Day 2024 will be held at HGF Limited, Leeds on Thursday 24th …

Event details